This summer, the diocese began discussions with the borough about a proposed redevelopment of the Saint-Eusèbe-de-Verceil Church site on Fullum Street.
Sorry for the long post, but I wanted to share a comprehensive update on this important and complex issue.
The church has been abandoned for more than a decade and has suffered two fires. The City has issued hundreds of thousands of dollars in fines, and the church has been boarded up since last year to prevent unauthorized entry.
In January, the diocese filed a lawsuit to force the City to issue a demolition permit. This could have left a vacant lot in the heart of the neighbourhood. This summer, the lawsuit was withdrawn to allow discussions to move forward.
In August, I met with the project team, who presented the main elements of their proposal:
- A building housing an intermediate care facility for seniors with declining autonomy (a level of care between a private seniors’ residence (RPA) and a long-term care facility (CHSLD))
- A rental apartment building
- The preservation and restoration of the rectory
- The creation of green spaces
However, this initial proposal called for the complete demolition of the church, with no elements preserved. For me, that was not an acceptable option.
The Comité de la rue Fullum has also launched a petition calling for the preservation of the façade and bell tower. It has already gathered more than 1,500 signatures. I support this request.
A few weeks ago, the borough’s Urban Planning Advisory Committee (CCU) reviewed the project. I was pleased to see that its members asked the diocese to revise the proposal to preserve these architectural elements, even if that meant increasing the number of housing units to help finance their preservation.
Last Friday, the diocese confirmed that it was working on a revised proposal to address these comments. Its intention is to preserve, at least in part, the façade, bell tower and church forecourt.
This is an important development, and I want to acknowledge the work of the diocese and its architects in moving toward a proposal that shows greater respect for the site’s heritage.
Several steps remain before the project can move forward, and you will have opportunities to share your comments:
- The diocese’s architects will finalize the revised proposal and submit it to the CCU for another review.
- If the CCU issues a favourable opinion, the project will go before the Demolition Review Committee, which will hold a public meeting where you can ask questions and share your views before a decision is made.
- If the Committee approves the proposal, it will then proceed to the appropriate municipal bodies for further consideration and votes.
Yes, the church is in very poor condition, and maintaining the status quo—a boarded-up building in the heart of the neighbourhood, next to a school, in the middle of a housing crisis—is not desirable. But this heritage building is an important landmark in Sainte-Marie, and we need to respect its heritage while taking into account the project’s technical and financial constraints. After all, this church was built and paid for by the people of the neighbourhood.
After several years of waiting, I believe we are getting closer to a project that will make better use of the site while honouring its history.
I will keep you informed of the next steps. In the meantime, I will continue working on this file with the mayor’s team, and I am pleased that we share the same commitment to preserving the site’s heritage.
Please don’t hesitate to share your comments with me. I have also emphasized to the diocese the importance of communicating transparently with neighbourhood residents. The project team is expected to release more details in the coming weeks.