Citizen update
Residents of Cartierville have recently derailed plans to convert a former convent into a retirement residence, citing concerns that « automobile traffic would increase in their neighbourhood ». This is how a journalist from La Presse described the decision of 192 local residents who exercised their rights by signing a register on October 13. By doing so, residents of the adjacent zone secured the right to a referendum on the proposed zoning amendments that would allow the former convent to be converted into a seniors’ residence.
The Société d’histoire d’Ahuntsic-Cartierville is saddened by this situation, which could leave the former convent complex of the Sisters of Mercy in a state of near abandonment following opposition from neighbouring residents. At this stage, it is difficult to predict what will happen next, as the developer has not indicated whether it intends to pursue the project in the face of a potential referendum. It should be noted that the developer failed to communicate its intentions effectively and to adequately explain the nature of the proposed development to neighbouring residents.
It is also unclear whether the borough will simply withdraw the proposed zoning amendment that would make the project possible, which would immediately bring discussions to an end. However, we know that other residents, who are committed to preserving the complex and ensuring that it serves a community-oriented purpose worthy of the Sisters of Mercy’s social mission, recognized the value of converting the main building into a seniors’ residence. They even produced a leaflet in an effort to address the shortcomings in the developer’s communications.
We are sharing the publication by the RPA-Miséricorde citizens’ committee so that you can better understand this project, which is now at risk.
We must nevertheless emphasize that it is premature to claim that the borough has approved the project, as no building permit has been issued.
It is naturally tempting to draw a parallel with the regrettable referendum held on June 10, 2012, concerning the proposed Maison des arts et des lettres on the grounds of Sophie-Barat School. At the time, the votes of fewer than one hundred neighbouring residents were enough to undo months of work on a cultural facility supported by hundreds of citizens, for which no replacement has been found to this day.
The present situation differs, however, because of the lack of public discussion within the community and the developer’s inadequate presentation of the project. We can only hope that more constructive discussions will take place before any potential referendum, and that these discussions will extend beyond neighbouring residents to consider the needs of the broader Cartierville community.
This link leads to an external website. Its content is the responsibility of its author and does not represent Héritage Montréal.



