Moreover, the replacement value of such a residence is unknown, and it is highly likely that any new building would lack the same historical, architectural, and heritage significance. A replacement structure might even appear discordant, of lower quality, and poorly integrated into the specific urban fabric of the Town of Mount Royal—something we have unfortunately witnessed all too often in recent years. We must not forget that our Garden City was recognized by Parks Canada as a National Historic Site of significance. We therefore have a responsibility to preserve its historical, urban, and heritage qualities.

Given that this home dates back to the early period of the city’s development as a Garden City, considering the surrounding green space that contributes to our urban oxygen levels, and with the understanding that the trees on the property should not be felled—and for all the reasons stated above—I formally oppose the issuance of a demolition permit for the residence at 159 Balfour Avenue.

On November 7, 2019, the Town of Mount Royal’s Demolition Permit Review Committee rejected the demolition request for 159 Balfour Avenue.

A second demolition request was submitted in 2022, but it too was denied. The house was eventually renovated in 2024. An extension was added, and the exterior cladding was modified.